no shopping

I think it’s time someone denounced recreational shopping.

Have you seen those car stickers that are all the rage right now? People stick them on their back windscreens and they represent each member of the family unit. They are EVERYWHERE here in Newcastle. On the back of every proud, carbon-emitting, oversized family vehicle.

You can buy them at the newsagents and they have a selection of stickers for each family member: for “dad”, “mum”, “girl”, “boy”, “dog”, “cat”, “grandma”, “grandpa” etc. You choose the one from the selection that most profoundly and intimately represents who you are. For example the boy might be on a skateboard, the girl might be wearing a bikini.

Anyway, I have noticed that a lot of times you see the family of stickers on someone’s car and the “mum” sticker is carrying bags, that, (since it is unlikely they indicate bags of her belongings suggesting she is homeless and must carry around her possessions at all times) one can only assume are shopping bags. The sticker that represents “mum” shows that she is shopping. And, shopping… her love of shopping, is what profoundly and intimately describes who she is.

 

Mum’s favourite thing, that which symbolises her personality more than anything else, is buying stuff. It doesn’t even matter what the stuff is, it’s just that she loves buying it.  It’s nothing new to “love shopping” – female characters in the mainstream media have long been depicted as “loving shopping”. Think of Sex and the City. There were four beloved women who “loved shopping”. The shit they bought (expensive clothes, shoes etc) practically defined them.

Why are women depicted this way? Can writers not think of a female character that has enough interesting personality traits such that they have to fall back on her consumption habits to give her supposed substance?

How is “buying stuff” a character trait?

And, moreover, why the fuck is shopping a recreational activity at all?

-Oh, that’s right, because we live in a society obsessed with excessive consumption, and most people don’t give a thought to the environmental degradation involved in obtaining the resources, the vulgar misuse of human labour in manufacturing the product, not to mention the pollution created in this process, or the fact that the product will spend more time as landfill than the relative five minutes it does being your prized possession…

(And for the record, I think that lots of men love buying stuff as much as women, but for some reason it is women who are depicted this way in the media.)

Do people not know what to do with themselves in their “leisure time” other than go and buy stuff? Consuming is perhaps the most immediately gratifying but ultimately unfulfilling way to pass the time… Were we to invest our energies into creatively engaging with the world (socially, artistically, physically or otherwise) we would probably have less need to “shop” for fulfillment.

Don’t even talk to me about “retail therapy”.

Capitalism, as we know it, promotes rampant, excessive, vulgar consumerism (just look at the ads, the media), and little time or energy is left for creative engagement with the world. It is so much easier to buy than to create.

Anyway, I think that the idea of “shopping” as a recreational activity, one that represents a person’s character, or something to “do” for “fun” should be put to rest. I think we all would do well to dig deep and figure out how we can creatively engage with the world and quit buying stuff for enjoyment.

But wait, what about the economy? Surely it will collapse if we stop spending money on needless products and then people will have no jobs. I know, I know. But this lifestyle is unsustainable, and something’s gotta give. The economy needs to be different and not built on needless consumption.

I denounce recreational shopping!

7 Responses to no shopping

  1. Like you I’ve never understood the whole retail therapy mindset. Maybe the people who seem to be attracted to recreational shopping just need to be exposed to sustainable pastimes. Good magazine suggests that people write down a list of free things they like doing, like going for a walk or visiting an art gallery. Link here

  2. I can’t help but feel personally attacked by some of your blogs Beccy, though maybe it’s just because I don’t share the same extreme opinions as you. I don’t put stickers on my car but i don’t care if others do. And it doesn’t bother me if my daughter decides she likes princesses (because I know she’ll get over it). But maybe I’m also guilty of some of the things you protest about so ‘passionately’. Like shopping. Most girls like shopping… there is such a variety of clothing items for women, it’s hard not to enjoy browsing the racks/shelves, new or used (and we know you “LOVE” it too: Extreme Opinions May 31, 2011). Sure, we all get pleasure out of having new items, but i think if you buy stuff just randomly then i don’t think the you get the same endorphin rush as you would if you really needed/wanted a particular item and went and bought it. Mindless spending is possibly more of a mental health issue that is thought it would bring pleasure, but actually leaves emptiness.

    Don’t get me wrong. I only buy what I need (most of the time), and I don’t defend those that mindlessly spend on ‘junk’. I do feel your pain to a point. I dislike waste. Of anything. If things are useless (like most of the stuffed toys my children have received as gifts in the last few years) then they inadvertently end up in the junk cycle of life until they end up at the dump. I could go on about my own opinions here, but there’s no point. I felt the way you feel now many years ago, ie, disgusted at the destruction of our natural environment to sustain our way of life. But I eventually learned to live with it because without dedicating my whole life to it (as in fully fledged activist), there’s not much I can do about it except be mindful of the way I and my family live. If you can come up with some awesomely creative way to create a totally sustainable future then all praises to you. But obviously no-one has THE answer. And that’s why things continue the way they are.

    Being a fellow novocastrian, I fear of running into you on the street in case you see my little girl dressed all in pink, or heaven forbid, her fairy dress (all her choice), and my boy in blue, all while I’m perusing the shops (just for a moment while my kids are both tolerating it). I feel I would be unaccepted as an acquaintance of Betty Joe Schtuart. But I can accept that. :)

  3. P.A. tells it how it is again. Loved this post.

  4. Chanel – respect to your honesty.

    You wouldn’t be the first to feel personally attacked by my rants :)

    I attack cultural practises that I find problematic/abhorrent. We live in a world where there is much that is worthy of criticism, in my mind, and I’m just hurling it out there. I could do it in a more moderate, mild-mannered way but that would be so boring to me, besides it’s just not my style…

    I realise some find the way I present ideas on this blog a bit confronting. But that’s what it is and I won’t be offended if you don’t read it. I love strong opinions, even when someone has a strong opinion that I don’t agree with, if they present a convincing argument then I am happy to engage with it, maybe to argue against it, or perhaps be convinced by it.

    If I feel judged by what someone has said I would hope to consider whether or not it was a judgement I took to heart, in which case it might be something worth thinking about changing. And if I thought their judgement was rubbish, I would treat it as such. If you are feeling judged by what I write and it makes you uncomfortable is it because the judgement resonates? And if you feel judged and think the judgement is rubbish, then… disregard. (I know that “being judgemental” has a bad name, but I kinda love it when people are judgemental, it means they have opinions and feel strongly about things, and if you don’t agree, then you can have an argument and figure out exactly what you think and why you think it, and I find that a very satisfying process. That’s how I like to operate anyway! Obviously not everyone feels this way, in which case maybe this blog is not for them :) )

    As for the shopping thing, yes, I confessed in the other post to love buying and having new clothes, but the whole point of that post was that I was feeling disgusted with myself for my consumer practises, so I changed them. (haven’t bought any new clothes since writing that, incidentally.)

    My judgements are for cultural practises that I get disgusted by, and sometimes it is me who is participating in these practises, so I judge myself for that, and aspire to act differently. I know it’s pretty impossible to live a perfect life but I am always thinking about how to bring my practises in line with my beliefs.

  5. Kimberly – yes we must take it upon ourselves to find joy in passing time without consuming.

  6. Beccy, I understand this is your blog and you can write whatever the hell you want. I enjoy reading it because most of your blogs are interesting and provide food for thought. Obviously some of them I don’t agree with and I guess I was just expressing that! If you continue writing them I’ll continue reading them (because I can’t help myself, even if they irk me). :)

  7. i saw a sticker on the back of a ute that said ‘fuck your family’ in the same text as is on the ‘family’ stickers.

    i laughed…

    i dislike the stickers, but realistically i put them in the same category as the (in)famous ones of the little boy pissing on the ford.holden/chevy logo. much like I’m sure they consider my ‘fuck taxis’ sticker i guess.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s